Sweet Desserts

This simple dessert idea has the perfect combination of milk, eggs, sugar, and nutmeg, no one will know how easy it was to prepare this Amish Custard Pie! This homemade dessert recipe deserves a spot on your list of Easter treats! Pin this.

Instant Chocolate Pudding is a decadent and thick Valentine's day dessert perfect if you want to satisfy your sweet tooth this love month! This Valentine's day recipe only needs five ingredients to make. Make some for yourself or bring it as a gift to your special someone!

Amish Strawberry Pie is light and fresh and piled high with freshly picked sweet strawberries! This Valentine's day dessert starts with a light and flaky crust and fresh strawberries. It will be a family favorite in no time! Save this Valentine's day idea!

Grandma's Shoofly Pie starts with a thick crust and sweet molasses filling. This traditional Amish pie has a unique texture and amazing flavor. This Valentine's day dessert is best paired with coffee. Impress your special someone with this Valentine's day recipe!

The perfect combination of milk, eggs, sugar, and nutmeg, no one will know how easy it was to prepare this Amish Custard Pie. This dessert deserves a spot on your list of Valentine's day desserts! Cold or warm weather, this pie holds no boundaries. Happy Valentine's baking!

Make your spring mornings extra indulgent with this spring food idea! This Cream Cheese Strawberry Stuffed French toast is covered with a cinnamon and sugar coating and filled with cream cheese and juicy strawberries. Mornings never looked this yummy. Save this spring breakfast recipe!

Looking for the perfect Valentine's day cookie? Try these Amish Sugar Cookies! This modern adaptation of the classic recipe produces the softest, no-fuss sugar cookies that will ever come out of your oven. Perfect as a gift for your special someone this Valentine's day!

When all else fails, trust that this Amish Pie Crust won't. This baking recipe is the perfect crust for anything! From apple pies to pot pies, it will be the best holding vessel for your yummy dessert recipes! Its delicate, light, flaky and addicting to eat. Save this pin!

Homemade candy has never been easier! This easy dessert to impress requires a few staple ingredients and a little bit of time. Amish Caramel is soft, chewy, melt-in-your-mouth – it is the perfect sweet treat to set out for gift-giving! Check out the variations for this dessert idea!

Made with real ingredients, this Carrot Cake is a Valentine's day treat you never knew you needed! This homemade Valentine's dessert is perfect for beginners because it is less fussy than other cakes. Topped with cream cheese frosting, this makes for a sweet and delightful treat!

Instant Chocolate Pudding is a decadent Valentine's dessert that only needs five ingredients to make! This thick and sweet treat is perfect as a simple gift to your special someone on Valentine's or when you just want to satisfy your sweet tooth. Pin this Valentine's day treat!

Homemade Apple Fritters is a cakey batter incorporated with juicy apples. This quick and easy snack only needs a few simple ingredients to make, in under 30 minutes! Topped with a sweet glaze, this sweet treat will remind you of a stuffed funnel cake – but better! Pin this for later.

These Amish Buttermilk Cookies are a must-have for back to school season! Drizzled with a thick caramelized glaze, this soft and puffy treats will go so fast. It's a good thing each batch of this recipe makes nearly 50 pieces each! Enjoy them as a snack or dessert!