Want the dirt on oil vs. gel cleansers? First, let’s talk skin-type. If you’re dry or sensitive, Neutrogena Ultra Light Cleansing Oil has your name on it. Bonus: It removes makeup and waterproof sunscreen, sans pulling and tugging (which can cause those pesky little lines around the eyes). Now if your skin’s on the oilier side, Vichy Fresh Cleansing Gel gives you a refreshing, deeper clean while eliminating surface oil and acne-causing bacteria. Dirt dished out.